Herbalife Nutritional Program * Characteristics: substitutes 2 meals a day with Herbalife "shakes" and tablets. * Strengths: one meal per day of regular food advised. Shakes generally include non-fat dry milk. * Weaknesses: heavy confidence in Herbalife powders and tablets; suggested rate of weight loss is too high (2 1/2 to 7 1/2 pounds/week). Ultra Slim Fast * Characteristics: weight loss program recommends two shakes/day (powder and milk), a snack and a complete dinner of 500 to 650 calories. * Strengths: plan encourages regular exercise. * Weaknesses: promotes use of Ultra Slim Fast Frozen Entrees and snack bars; does not teach good eating habits. * Comments: difficult to maintain weight loss once shakes are discontinued.
Mega-Thin/100 Formula * Characteristics: drink Mega-Thin formula. Eat according to specified diet. Formula contains "anti-fat weapon." * Weaknesses: diet de-emphasized; behavior modification lacking; emphasis on speed of weight loss. * Comments: formula most likely contains an appetite suppressant.
Diet Pills Containing PPA * Characteristics: take capsule one or two times per day; follow diet plan that comes with capsules; pills suppress appetite, but weight loss occurs from following diet plan; the majority of brands have a diet plan enclosed; many of these are good diets. * Weaknesses: pills produce side effects that have not been effectively studied. * Comments: weight loss comes from following the diet, not from taking the pills.
Nestlé’s Sweet Success * Characteristics: weight loss program recommends three shakes/ day (powder and skim milk), and a complete dinner of 500 to 650 calories. * Strengths: low-fat, nutrient rich foods are encouraged for dinner. * Weaknesses: does not promote healthy eating habits. * Comments: difficult to maintain weight loss once shakes are discontinued
Diet Pills Containing Ephedra (also called Ma Huang)
* Characteristics: claims to promote weight loss; take tablets daily; suggested number of tablets varies depending on the product manufacturer. * Weaknesses: pills can produce potentially life-threatening side effects; side effects have not been effectively studied. * Comments: ephedra is a central nervous system stimulant that suppresses appetite; frequently combined with caffeine, which can increase risk for unfavorable side effects; not proven safe or effective for weight loss.
Glucomannan Supplements
* Characteristics: follow 1,000-calorie per day diet and take two capsules before each meal, claim that capsules reduce appetite and decrease food absorption. * Weaknesses: claim weight loss of 1/2 to 1 lb/day; sensational, nutritionally inaccurate presentation. * Comments: glucomannans are naturally occurring food thickeners, not yet proven safe or effective; weight loss probably comes from following the diet.
|